What happened
A scaffolding company has been fined after a trainee scaffolder died in a five-metre fall from a partially erected scaffold, according to the HSE Media Centre.
On 5 July 2023, Michael Swales was working for Ask Scaffolding Ltd, which had been contracted to provide scaffolding services for a residential housing development near Ripon in North Yorkshire. Mr Swales and a colleague were erecting scaffolding at the front of a two-storey house under construction when he fell five metres after standing on an unsecured scaffolding board. Emergency services attended, but Mr Swales died at the scene.
The HSE investigation found that Ask Scaffolding Ltd had failed to ensure work at height was carried out in a safe manner, so far as was reasonably practicable. Safe zones had not been established, and neither Mr Swales nor his colleague was using a harness or lanyard. A post-accident inspection identified that guardrails had not been installed where they should have been, and the investigation found previous scaffolding work had also not followed the guidance. Several witnesses indicated that operatives regularly worked without following the guidance.
HSE Inspector David Beaton said: "This tragic accident underlines the importance of those in control of scaffolding work making sure that it is being done safely and in accordance with industry guidance, and the potential consequences where this is not done."
Ask Scaffolding Ltd, of Pickering, pleaded guilty to breaching Regulation 4(1)(c) of the Work at Height Regulations 2005. The company was fined £16,000 and ordered to pay £8,000 in costs and a £2,000 victim surcharge at Leeds Magistrates' Court on 4 November 2026.
Why it matters to contractors
This is a case about the basics done — or not done — consistently. The guidance identifies collective protection, the 'Scaffolder's Safe Zone', as the primary means of preventing falls, with personal fall protection (harness and lanyard) used where a scaffolder is working without a safe zone. Both lines of defence were absent here.
The detail that should stop every supervisor in their tracks is the finding that unsafe practice wasn't a one-off. The HSE noted previous work and regular practice didn't follow the guidance. That points to a culture problem, not a single bad shift. When corners become routine, it's usually because no one checks — and for a trainee learning the trade, what they see every day is what they learn is 'normal'.
Erecting, dismantling and altering scaffold is exactly the phase where falls happen, because the collective protection is going up or coming down. That's precisely when the safe-zone system and personal protection matter most.
What to check on your site
- Safe zones first. Is a Scaffolder's Safe Zone established before work starts at each lift? Collective protection is the primary control, not an afterthought.
- Fall protection where there's no safe zone. Are harnesses and lanyards available, inspected, and actually clipped on when a safe zone can't be maintained?
- Guardrails installed as you go. Are guardrails fitted where they should be at every stage of erection and alteration?
- No standing on unsecured boards. Are boards secured and the deck checked before anyone steps onto it?
- Trainees supervised. Is competent supervision in place so new operatives learn the correct method, not the shortcut?
- Inspection records. Are partially completed scaffolds inspected and documented before use?
- Challenge the 'normal'. Does anyone actually watch how the gang works day to day — or is bad practice going unseen?
SafetyPod documents that help
Getting the method and controls written down is the first step to making sure they're followed. Our Scaffolder Risk Assessment Pack covers access equipment, working at height, MEWPs and scaffold inspection in one purchase. Pair it with the Site Monitoring Bundle so supervisors have the inspection forms to catch bad practice before it becomes routine, and the RAMS & Permits templates to set out a safe sequence of work for erection, alteration and dismantling.
New to writing a method statement? Our plain-English guide to RAMS explains what goes in one and when you need it. These templates are a solid starting point you edit for your site — they don't make anyone compliant on their own; your controls and supervision do that.
The takeaway
Falls from height remain the biggest killer in construction. A safe zone, guardrails in place, and fall protection used when there's no safe zone are not optional extras — they're the job. Check your access work today.
Get the Scaffolder Risk Assessment Pack and build the paperwork behind your safe systems of work.