In early October 2026, HSE published two prosecutions with the same legal breach at the centre: regulation 4(1) of the Work at Height Regulations 2005. That regulation says work at height must be properly planned, appropriately supervised and carried out as safely as reasonably practicable. One case involved a ladder moved near overhead power lines on a house. The other involved a first floor that had been opened up during refurbishment. In both, a worker died.
Neither case turned on unusual or complicated work. Both came down to planning. This article sets out what HSE reported and what each case means for a small contractor's paperwork and site practice.
What HSE reported
Ladder near overhead power lines (Chester, 2024). HSE reported on 6 October 2026 that a sole trader painter and decorator had been sentenced. A 24-year-old trainee painter died on 29 July 2024 while he and a colleague were moving a fully extended ladder at the gable end of a house. The ladder either touched an overhead power line or came close enough for an electrical arc to form. His colleague suffered burns.
HSE found that:
- The work at height had not been properly planned, supervised or carried out safely.
- The equipment and methods were unsuitable, and the risk from the overhead lines had not been adequately assessed or controlled.
- There were issues with the training and competence of the workers.
- The original plan (a tower scaffold and ladders) was itself unsuitable. In practice the job changed to ladders throughout.
The sole trader pleaded guilty to breaching regulation 4(1). He received 16 weeks' imprisonment, suspended for 12 months, and was ordered to pay £10,645 costs.
Fall through an open first floor (Gloucestershire, 2022). HSE reported on 2 October 2026 that W G Carter Limited had been fined £120,000, with £5,247 costs. A 59-year-old carpenter fell through an unsafe first floor on 30 August 2022 while replacing rotten joists. Large parts of the floor had been stripped back, some joists were missing or unsecured, and other workers were still removing floorboards in the same area. He fell to the concrete floor below and died the next day.
HSE found that:
- Workers could get into areas where flooring and supports had been removed, without enough measures to stop them falling.
- Other workers lifting boards made the risk worse while the work went on.
- After the incident, the company switched to installing joists from below using suitable work at height equipment and prevented access to the first floor.
HSE also noted that falls from height accounted for over a quarter of work-related deaths in 2025/26. Its annual fatality figures put that at 31 of 126 worker deaths. Construction had the highest number of deaths of any industry, at 25.
Lesson 1: the plan has to match the job you actually do
Regulation 4 isn't satisfied by having a plan on paper. In the Chester case the written approach was already unsuitable, and the work then changed to ladders throughout. Before anyone goes up, your risk assessment and method statement should answer:
- Can the work be avoided at height? Regulation 6 makes this the first question, and HSE's brief guide INDG401 explains the order: avoid, prevent, then minimise.
- What equipment will you use, and why? If you choose ladders, the reason has to come from the risk. HSE's ladder guidance says ladders are for cases where equipment with more fall protection isn't justified because the risk is low and use is short. It adds that short duration alone is not the deciding factor. As a guide, HSE recommends other equipment if the task means staying on a leaning ladder or stepladder for more than 30 minutes at a time.
- What happens if the method changes? Write down who can approve a change and when the assessment must be reviewed. Management Regulations regulation 3 requires a review where there's reason to think it's no longer valid or there's been a significant change.
SafetyPod templates:
- The Working at Height Risk Assessment (£3.99) covers the hierarchy of controls, equipment selection and sign-off. A free version is on our free templates page.
- For ladder work, the Using Ladders Risk Assessment (£3.99) and Stepladders Risk Assessment (£3.99) cover the ladder-specific checks.
Lesson 2: look up before you lift, move or carry a ladder
HSE's guidance on overhead lines, GS6, lists ladders and scaffold tubes among the equipment involved in overhead line incidents. It warns that a wire doesn't need to be touched, because electricity can arc across small gaps. The guidance covers:
- Your planning zone. Manage the risk if you'll be working within 10 m of the line, measured horizontally at ground level from below the nearest wire.
- Removing the risk first. Ask the line's owner whether it can be diverted or switched off. The owner needs time to act and may charge.
- If the line stays live. Your site-specific risk assessment must show how the work can be done safely. If it can't, it shouldn't be done.
- Moving long objects. Carry them horizontally and close to the ground. No ladder, pole or hand tool should be able to get into the exclusion zone around the line.
HSE's overhead power lines page for construction adds that you shouldn't mistake lines on wooden poles for telephone wires. CDM 2015 regulation 25 sets the legal duty for overhead cables on construction work.
In practice, put the overhead line check on the permit, not just in the RAMS. A Ladder Permit to Work (£3.99) has sections for the work description, hazards, controls, authorisation, time limits and close-out. That's the place to record "overhead lines checked: none within 10 m / owner contacted / ladder to be carried lowered", and who signed it off.
Lesson 3: when you open up a floor, control access to it
In the Gloucestershire case, the danger came from the work itself, as joists and boards came out. Workers could still walk into the area while others kept stripping it. Two parts of the law apply directly:
- Prevent falls (regulation 6). Use edge protection, covers, boarding or nets, or work from below, as the company did after the incident.
- Danger areas (regulation 11). Where there's a risk of falling or of being hit by falling objects, the area must, so far as reasonably practicable, have devices that stop unauthorised people getting in. It must also be clearly marked.
A Limitation of Access Permit (£3.99) is the simple site tool for this. It defines the area, the hazard, who may enter and for how long, and who closes it out. For higher-risk tasks, the Work at Height Permit (£3.99) records authorisation and controls before work starts. If the floor removal involves temporary supports, log them on a Temporary Works Register (£3.99).
Lesson 4: supervision and competence are part of the plan
Both cases mention supervision, and the Chester case also raised training and competence. HSE's ladder guidance says anyone using a ladder must be competent, or be working under the supervision of a competent person if they're being trained. Competence covers knowing how to assess the risk, when a ladder is right (and when it isn't), and which type to use.
For trainees and young workers, put the supervision arrangements in writing. Who is with them, and what are they not allowed to do alone? Brief the whole crew before the job. The Ladders & Stepladders Toolbox Talk and Working at Height Toolbox Talk are £3.99 each and include an attendance record.
Lesson 5: check the kit every day
HSE says the person using the ladder should do a pre-use check at the start of the working day and after anything changes, for example if it's dropped or moved from dirty ground to a clean surface. Check:
- The stiles
- The feet
- The rungs
- The locks
- The platform and treads on stepladders
If you're using a MEWP instead, the checks and the LOLER examination are different. See our MEWP risk assessment and inspection guide.
Get the work at height paperwork in place
| Need | Template | Price |
|---|---|---|
| Ladder task sign-off and overhead line check | Ladder Permit to Work | £3.99 |
| Ladder risk assessment | Using Ladders Risk Assessment | £3.99 |
| General working at height risk assessment | Working at Height Risk Assessment | £3.99 (free version) |
| Keeping people out of open floors and drop zones | Limitation of Access Permit | £3.99 |
| Higher-risk work at height authorisation | Work at Height Permit | £3.99 |
| MEWP risk assessment | Using MEWPs Risk Assessment | £3.99 |
| The whole access set (16 documents) | Scaffolder & access pack | £14.99 |
| Every template | Membership | £69 a year |
See every option on the pricing page. Our templates are editable Word files. Fill them in for the actual job and have them checked by a competent person. A form on its own isn't a safe system of work.
FAQ
What does regulation 4 of the Work at Height Regulations require?
Every employer must make sure work at height is properly planned, appropriately supervised and carried out as safely as reasonably practicable. Planning includes choosing the right equipment, and planning for emergencies and rescue. Work must also only go ahead when the weather doesn't put people at risk (regulation 4).
Are ladders banned on UK sites?
No. HSE says ladders and stepladders are not banned. They can be sensible for low-risk, short-duration tasks, but they shouldn't automatically be your first choice. The decision must come from a risk assessment.
How close to an overhead power line is too close?
HSE's GS6 says to manage the risk for work within 10 m horizontally of the nearest wire. It sets minimum exclusion zones by voltage, and the line owner can advise on safe clearance. Always assume a line is live unless the owner confirms otherwise.
Do I need a permit for ladder work?
The law doesn't require a ladder permit as such. A permit is a common way to show the task was assessed, authorised and checked, including for overhead lines, and many principal contractors require one on their sites.
What's a limitation of access permit for?
It controls who can enter a defined hazardous area, such as an opened-up floor or a drop zone, and under what conditions. That helps you meet the danger area duty in regulation 11.
Case details are taken only from HSE's press releases of 2 and 6 October 2026. Statistics are from HSE's 1 July 2026 release. Sources checked 19 November 2026. This is general information for UK contractors and is not legal advice.
Written by Steven Noone, NEBOSH-qualified Health & Safety Manager. Last reviewed: 20 November 2026.